He built and sold a company. When he evaluates a nonprofit, he is not just evaluating the pitch. He is evaluating the person pitching.
The lesson
Donors weigh whether you can do what you say.
A different kind of fundraising talk
23 major donors. $110M in lifetime giving. What they said about why they say yes, why they stay, and why they quietly walk away.

$110M
donor giving
23
donor interviews
$3M+
raised
3,000+
donor asks
01 Discover
Is this mine to fund?
02 Purchase
Is this a good buy?
03 Deliver
Did you follow through?
and the loop repeats
01 Discover
Is this mine to fund?
02 Purchase
Is this a good buy?
03 Deliver
Did you follow through?
and the loop repeats
Nine lessons, each from a donor’s own story.
He built and sold a company. When he evaluates a nonprofit, he is not just evaluating the pitch. He is evaluating the person pitching.
The lesson
Donors weigh whether you can do what you say.
She and her husband left part of their estate to the symphony. “Our lives were changed through beauty. We give to things that create that in the world.”
The lesson
Every donor has a giving code. Some rejection has nothing to do with you.
Her top gift goes to medical missionaries. Not for the heroes. “I give because of my mom and dad.”
The lesson
Find where your mission meets their story.
The most sophisticated donor Nate met picked a nonprofit that gives beds to people who need them. “I know exactly what my dollars do.”
The lesson
If a donor cannot repeat what you do, they cannot feel their gift again.
A $900K renewal turned into a step-down and then zero, because the donor’s intent was not respected.
The lesson
Donors own the intent. You own the execution.
Asked for $50K again, he gave zero. “How could I give again if you haven’t told me what happened?”
The lesson
An open loop in a donor’s mind does not close on its own.
Plus a $1M donor who said “stop calling me,” and a $2K donor who became a $30K donor after one impact report.
Gift received
Thank-you sent
Impact shipped
Where most nonprofits stop
Donor hears about it
The most common, most preventable reason loyal donors leave.
If a tree falls in the forest and your donor does not hear it, it did not fall.
Everyone leaves with
Everything you need to slot Nate in
One page, one bio, one headshot. Ready to drop into your program.
Short and ready to paste.
High resolution, free to use when promoting the event.

Need something else? Book a time to discuss and ask.
The story behind the research.
01
$235K in debt
02
A $1M mentor said no
03
Four reasons, fixed in 9 months
04
Record revenue and record impact
Then Nate interviewed 23 major donors to learn the rest.
Nate Hilpert, founder of The Nonprofit Turnaround. Built a development department from scratch at HeartSupport. $3M+ raised, 3,000+ donor asks.
Watch Nate teach donor psychology start to finish.
Fundraising Masterclass on Donor Psychology: How Donors Decide to GiveFrom a live workshop
Thanks so much for this. This made fundraising not feel so daunting.
Emily, attendee of a Center for Nonprofit Success webinar
30 minutes. We will look at your audience and pick the format.